next up previous
Next: 4.2 Simulation Results Up: 4.1 Measurement Selection Previous: Theoretical Results

Actual Measurements

For practical reasons, the observations selected to achieve complete diagnosability of single faults by theoretical analysis may not be the best measurements to use. This may be because some of the chosen sensors are expensive or unreliable, or some measurement points may be hard to access. As an alternative, measurements that are not part of the ideal set of observations may be available, for example, regulations may require certain pressures and flows to be monitored. In case of the secondary cooling system, variables in the system that are typically hard to measure are flow variables because flow sensors for liquid sodium are imprecise and expensive.

Using only the observations that are currently available, tex2html_wrap_inline1340 , depicted by boxed variables in Fig. 7 and Fig. 8, single faults in the system are equally well diagnosable with the subset tex2html_wrap_inline1342 (see Table 3). The exception is tex2html_wrap_inline1344 . The number of observations in this set and the ideal set of selected measurements are the same, but higher order predictions are required to achieve the same diagnosis for the currently used set. This implies there are more likely interactions in multiple, cascading, fault scenarios for the current observations, which reduces the chance to making a complete or unique diagnosis.

   table371
Table 3: Fault discrimination based on actual measurement points.



Pieter J. Mosterman
Mon Aug 18 15:29:41 CDT 1997